By Quentin Fottrell

‘Ought to we be redecorating, going to Cancun and Disney World and getting takeout each evening as an alternative?’

Expensive Quentin,

I am a fairly lucky one that lives a fairly lucky life, and our annual family earnings at $160,000 is excessive in comparison with the remainder of the world. Nevertheless, we’re nonetheless fairly frugal — we cook dinner at house, drive outdated Hondas and do house repairs ourselves the place potential.

We put away about 20% of our earnings into retirement and faculty financial savings. Now we have greater than $1 million in retirement funds. This was totally on a cop’s wage, as I used to be a stay-at-home mom. My husband is now retired, and I went again to work.

I see folks with much less cash and greater bills (pupil loans, big mortgages, credit-card debt, and so forth.) residing a way more lavish life than we do. Our youngsters say that our small — however cute! — home is embarrassing, and other people right here within the suburbs see us as poor.

Are we lacking the boat? We needed to avoid wasting aggressively for retirement and our youngsters’ faculty prices. However ought to we be redecorating, going to Cancun and Disney World and getting takeout each evening as an alternative?

How are these different folks affording this luxe life? And if we keep this frugal, will we wind up wealthy however too outdated to spend the cash? I do not begrudge anybody else enjoyment and high-end stuff. I simply marvel if I am doing this unsuitable.

Thanks sincerely for studying my letter. It helped simply asking this out loud.

Frugal Spouse

Expensive Frugal,

Wealth doesn’t imply that you just drive a Tesla Mannequin X Plaid (TSLA), stay in a sought-after ZIP code, put on a flashy watch and/or take Instagrammable (META) holidays. In actual fact, that may imply the precise reverse. It will probably additionally imply that you’re much less rich than the individual subsequent door residing in a modest home that has not been decked out with electrical gates and a McMansion-style extension. Certainly, credit-card debt hit a document $866 billion within the third quarter of 2022, up 19% from the identical interval a 12 months earlier, in keeping with TransUnion’s (TRU) most up-to-date quarterly report.

Have you ever missed out? I feel you in all probability already know the reply to that query. You did not miss out on the recollections of dinner at house with your loved ones or taking holidays in your outdated, much-loved automobile, or by having the ability to relaxation your head on the pillow at evening, protected within the information that, regardless of not being a part of the 1%, you managed to accrue $1 million in retirement financial savings and preserve your residing prices low. Your own home is, little doubt, crammed with recollections. Good for you for not feeling the stress to consistently improve to a much bigger pile.

How are folks affording their existence? Some folks, significantly these within the tech sector — which, sadly, has suffered widespread layoffs in latest months — have sufficient to mess around with whereas maximizing their 401(ok)s and placing apart 12 months of bills for a wet day. However they do not symbolize the vast majority of Individuals. In actual fact, the non-public saving price — which means private saving as a proportion of disposable earnings — fell to 2.4% in November from 8.9% in November 2019, earlier than the coronavirus pandemic.

Certain, wealthier persons are paying extra taxes: Some economists say the non-public saving price might be falling as extra buyers pay capital features taxes on shares they bought within the final 12 months. Nonetheless, “extra financial savings” — the quantity households saved versus what they might have saved had it not been for COVID-19 and the ensuing job losses — hit $1.7 trillion by mid-2022. And $1.35 trillion of that was held by the highest and third earnings quartiles. To place that mid-2022 determine in context, within the second quarter of 2021, extra financial savings stood at $2.26 trillion.

However some say the latest lack of jobs within the tech sector doesn’t bode effectively for individuals who are solely residing for at the moment. Tom Siebel, a billionaire serial entrepreneur whose newest title is CEO of (AI), instructed my colleague Levi Sumagaysay final November: “Earlier than that is over, everybody will really feel the sting, giant firms and small.” He added, “All this bizarre, entitled conduct is coming to an finish. No extra folks working in pajamas at house, being paid in bitcoin. This period can be a zinger, sadly.” He additional cautioned a couple of vital downturn forward.

Ignore your mates and neighbors who’re residing it up at Disney World. The Disney trip website Mousehacking stated its baseline Disney World (DIS) trip for a household of 4 — two adults, one little one 10 or older, and one little one aged 3 to 9 — prices $6,320, or $316 per individual per evening, in 2023. “This consists of flights, transportation to and from Disney World, a five-night keep at Pop Century, five-day tickets with out park hopper, Genie+ at two parks, and quick-service meals, snacks, and two desk service meals,” the positioning says.

Name me old school, however I might reasonably e-book an Airbnb (ABNB) in an outdated market city. Plus, fun-park rides depart me with a headache — second solely to the ultimate invoice.

Observe Quentin Fottrell on Twitter.

You may electronic mail The Moneyist with any monetary and moral questions associated to coronavirus at

Try the Moneyist personal Fb group, the place we search for solutions to life’s thorniest cash points. Readers write to me with all types of dilemmas. Submit your questions, inform me what you wish to know extra about, or weigh in on the most recent Moneyist columns.

The Moneyist regrets he can not reply to questions individually.

Extra from Quentin Fottrell:

‘We are able to virtually end one another’s sentences’: I am getting married in 2023. I need a prenup. She desires to merge our funds. What’s my subsequent transfer?

‘I wish to meet somebody wealthy. Is that so unsuitable?’ I am 46, earn $210,000, and personal a $700,000 house. I am uninterested in courting ‘losers.’

‘I wish to thrive’: I am 29, work part-time, and left a 15-year abusive relationship. How do I get again on my ft financially?

-Quentin Fottrell


(END) Dow Jones Newswires

01-14-23 0953ET

Copyright (c) 2023 Dow Jones & Firm, Inc.